A cultural rise in substance use is hitting young mothers particularly hard, a new study has found, showing they’re landing in hospital at much higher rates than women without children.
New data reveals substance-related emergency visits by mothers with dependent children increased almost five per cent a year between 2008 and 2024, compared to an increase of just two per cent among women without children.
More glaringly, emergency visits for mothers younger than 25 years old rose about eight per cent a year — an increase nearly four times as fast as their peers.
“Substance use has been increasing in North America, driven by overlapping opioid and stimulant epidemics, coupled with changing social norms and policies related to cannabis, and rising alcohol consumption for females,” the study reads.
“Our findings suggest that birthing parents have not been protected from these trends and, rather, may have been disproportionately affected, particularly those younger than 25 years,” it adds.
The study was led by Dr. Colleen Webber, an investigator at the Bruyère Health Research Institute in Ottawa, and published in the Canadian Medical Association Journal. It found the increases were highest for amphetamines, opioids and cannabis, but that alcohol is still the biggest driver of emergency visits and hospital admissions for substance use.
Webber said she and her co-authors recognized there had been overlapping drug crises happening, with the rise of opioid and methamphetamine use, changing patterns of alcohol use, the legalization of cannabis and the introduction of fentanyl into the drug supply. The research on these topics is plentiful, she said, but that data focuses on the population at large.
“There hasn’t been a lot of focus on parents, particularly once a mom leaves the pregnancy and postpartum period,” Webber said.
“At the same time, we don’t really have any reason just to suspect that mothers, as a group, would be spared from what’s happening in the broader population in terms of rising health harms related to drugs and alcohol. But there was no evidence on it.”
So, they dug into the data and found not only were emergency room visits for mothers on the rise, but so were hospital admissions for issues of intoxication, overdose and extreme symptoms of withdrawal.
Hospitalization for substance use among all mothers with dependent children rose from 99 per 100,000 people in 2008 to 259 in 2024. Broken down further, for mothers under 25, that number skyrocketed from 199 per 100,000 people in 2008 to 504 in 2024.
Among women who did not have children, admissions also rose, but not as much. It went from 136 admissions per 100,000 people in 2008 to 209 in 2024.
The study does not explain what is driving these trends, and the authors emphasized they were not clear about whether it’s motherhood itself that’s resulting in increasing substance use.
They said, however, the higher rates in younger mothers “likely relate to other factors leading to having children earlier in life that may also increase the risk of substance use.”
Young parenthood “may be a marker of intersecting social and structural disadvantages,” the study explained, including economic instability, housing insecurity, trauma exposure and mental health challenges.
Natasha McBrearty, executive director of Youville Centre in Ottawa, a not-for-profit organization dedicated to helping young mothers, said this is likely true.
The Ottawa-based centre works with about 40 young parents a year. They did a point-in-time count last year that found about 50 per cent of their clients were either homeless, unstably housed or newly housed in social housing.
On top of that, they often face many obstacles in life, such as food insecurity, intergenerational struggles and the stigma that comes along with being a young parent.
“A lot of these young women are living in poverty. We always say it’s not the fact you’re having a baby that’s a problem, it’s the fact you’re encountering all these barriers,” McBrearty said.
“It’s all of these pieces, especially when you’re living in poverty and facing multiple barriers; it’s just kind of the perfect soup. And then you have a system that doesn’t have a whole lot of preventative help. So, it’s not entirely surprising.”
Mental health can also play a role in determining someone’s path toward substance use, the study suggested. It found that, compared with other women, birthing parents were more likely to have a higher prevalence of mood disorder-related health care use.
Parental mental health has been recognized as an urgent public health concern, they added — including in a 2024 advisory from the United States Surgeon General “highlighting the disproportionate stress burden experienced by parents and its downstream effects on child well-being.”
This underscores the importance of understanding substance-related harms in the parent population, they said, calling for more targeted supports that address the social determinants of substance use among young mothers.
McBrearty agreed. She said there is an overall lack of accessible counselling options and other free resources in the city, which makes it difficult to get to the root of the problem.
“Our focus, our mandate, is to help them complete their high school education, and that’s so important because education is one of the most important and well-researched social determinants of health,” she said.
“So, our thinking is if we can help get them an education, we increase their health and social and employment opportunities, and then we try to remove every barrier that’s getting in the way of that.”
Drug and alcohol use can be detrimental to the mothers themselves, Webber said, but the effects don’t end there. Growing up with a parent who has a substance use disorder is considered an adverse childhood experience, and the study points out that this can increase a child’s risks of poor health, developmental challenges and future substance use.
“That has really important implications first for the care of mothers and second for children since most mothers will have kids they are caring for,” said co-author Dr. Daniel Myran, also an investigator at the Bruyère Health Research Institute.
“Previous studies have found that many children in the United States have lost a parent to an overdose. But living with a parent who has a substance use disorder can have very negative impacts on a child, and this has not received much focus. Our study suggests an increasing number of children in Ontario may be growing up with a mother who has a serious substance use disorder.”
The Youville Centre recognizes this, and part of its mandate is to help the children of the young mothers they serve in its child development program. Their aim is to give the children an “optimal start in life” while the parents work on themselves.
“These issues don’t just happen overnight. These are issues that probably were apparent very early in life. The early intervention and early prevention piece is huge,” McBrearty said.
Despite the increases over time, the overall use of substances among birthing parents remains relatively low. By 2024, approximately one in 200 and one in 386 birthing parents had a substance-related emergency department visit or hospital admission in the past year, respectively.
And while that doesn’t seem like much on the whole, Webber said the impacts are widespread.
“Anybody would look at that and say it’s still fairly rare. But that turns out to be about 6,000 moms per year that are going to the emergency department for drugs and alcohol. Most of those will have kids at home with them,” she said.
“It’s probably the tip of the iceberg in that there’s probably other moms out there that are struggling with drugs and alcohol but not ending up in the hospital or the emergency department.”
Those women are often afraid to seek help, Webber said — there’s a stigma attached to being a mother with substance use issues, and many people will avoid seeking help because they’re afraid of being judged or worried about losing their children.
“We need to make an environment where we are putting protections in place, but we’re also providing support for these parents so that when they do seek help, that we’re able to help them,” she said.
Related
- Bruyère workers rally in bid to force Ottawa hospital to reverse job cuts
- New research hub to focus on innovative cell and gene therapies
Take control of your search results. Make the Ottawa Citizen a preferred source on Google and see verified local reporting first.
For more health news and content around diseases, conditions, wellness, healthy living, drugs, treatments and more, head to Healthing.ca – a member of the Postmedia Network.