Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre is weighing in on Quebecor Inc.‘s proposed takeover of Telus Corp., saying Prime Minister Mark Carney’s comments on the issue show he “favours the corporate power brokers over the consumers.”
On Wednesday, the prime minister said more competition, lower prices and better service would be key to any federal decision if ongoing talks between the companies culminate in an agreement for Ottawa to review.
While Carney didn’t comment directly on Quebecor’s proposal, he said that under certain circumstances and depending on the market structure, an oligopoly situation can lead to more competition with fewer players, though he didn’t elaborate further.
Poilievre said he has “never seen any economist anywhere in the world” make that argument.
“Mr. Carney has been wrong about a lot of things, but I have never seen a more ridiculous economic analysis from anyone than what he said the other day, that less competition actually brings prices down,” he told reporters Friday.
“As for us Conservatives, we haven’t seen the proposal yet. Shareholders haven’t approved it, nor has the Competition Bureau had a chance to investigate. But … we will judge this decision based on one principle: Will it lower costs for consumers?”
Aidan Hollis, an economics professor at the University of Calgary, said in a previous interview that having more industry players generally leads to greater competition, but that is not always the case. He said a possible exception is if an “inefficient” competitor with a small market share is absorbed by another player, which could result in a “more effective competitor.”
Quebecor revealed Monday it is eyeing a $31-billion takeover of Telus in a cash-and-stock deal. However Telus has cited “serious concerns” with the offer, including how it could survive regulatory scrutiny. The Vancouver-based company’s president and CEO Victor Dodig said the offer also undervalues Telus.
Telus has not accepted the proposal and is continuing to review the bid. Dodig and Quebecor president and CEO Pierre Karl Péladeau are slated to meet Monday to discuss next steps.
Péladeau has pitched the merger as a way to save cash by combining networks, spectrum and operations, which would boost investment capacity. He said a stronger company would be better positioned to protect “sovereignty” in the Canadian telecommunications sector as foreign competitors like Elon Musk’s Starlink gain market share.
Telecom sector analysts also believe the proposal could prompt a competing offer from Bell Canada-owner BCE. Inc., which already has a network sharing agreement in place with Telus.
Any potential transaction would likely lead to reviews by the Competition Bureau, the CRTC and Innovation, Science and Economic Development Canada (ISED).
“When it comes to the Quebecor proposal to buy Telus … this is an intent at this point and we have very strong regulatory processes,” said Industry Minister Mélanie Joly on Friday.
“The Competition Bureau, the CRTC and the powers we have under the Telecommunications (Act) and the Radiocommunication Act will be enforced.”
Those potential reviews would run in parallel but are not dependent on one another, noted Scotiabank analyst Maher Yaghi in a report Friday. He pointed out that the Competition Bureau investigates under the Competition Act, with the Competition Tribunal deciding contested cases, while Joly has the authority through ISED to approve spectrum licence transfers under the Radiocommunication Act.
Meanwhile, the CRTC approves changes in control of broadcasting licences under the Broadcasting Act.
“Each body applies a different test, and clearance from one does not bind another,” Yaghi noted.
“The Bureau asks whether the deal is likely to substantially lessen or prevent competition. ISED looks at how scarce spectrum is allocated and at the ability of competitors to compete. The CRTC applies the broadcasting public interest and Canadian ownership rules.”
He said the 2023 merger of Rogers Communications Inc. and Shaw Communications Inc. showed a deal can win before the Competition Tribunal and still depend on a spectrum decision from the industry minister.
When Ottawa approved that takeover, it also implemented a moratorium on the transfer of spectrum licences, which remains in place. That stands as the first regulatory hurdle for Quebecor to clear, said Yaghi.
He added that increased concentration in the sector could require significant divestitures in order to satisfy competition concerns, estimating a combined company would likely need to shed 3.1 million to 3.8 million subscribers.
“At this stage, trying to assign deal probabilities creates false precision. Too many variables that will ultimately determine the outcome are unknown,” Yaghi said.
“At this point and without a material change in position by Quebecor, the Competition Bureau’s review will be a difficult gate to pass. Without a revised spectrum framework and a defined remedy package … we see low completion odds.”
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 20, 2026.
Companies in this story: (TSX:TSX:QBR.B, TSX:T)