Many residents in a west-end Toronto neighbourhood say they are frustrated with Metrolinx after they say repeated requests for noise mitigation measures near a future GO Transit station have been dismissed.
Metrolinx and its crews have been building a new Bloor-Lansdowne GO Transit station over the past couple of years to provide a new connection to the transit network’s Barrie line.
Currently, there is just one set of tracks that runs close to several neighbourhoods west of Lansdowne Avenue and north from the main rail corridor that connects to Union Station. Under the expansion plan, crews are working to add a second set of tracks in the same corridor along with a multi-use path in parts.
At Bloor Street West, there will be a new station to eventually accommodate future all-day, two-way train traffic that could see trains coming every 15 minutes in peak periods.
Paula Heaney lives at a century-old building on St. Helens Avenue. She showed CityNews the impacts of the construction, and crews have cleared an area out less than five feet from the entrances to some people’s units. She said crews have begun preparing a retaining wall next to where the path and station platform will eventually be going.
Without noise protection, GO trains can quickly and briefly drown out conversations. Heaney said she and others have tried to get Metrolinx to respond to their concerns without luck, adding the organization hasn’t acted as a good neighbour.
“In terms of one-way communication, they’re not so bad, but when they’re listening, they don’t listen to feedback. They’re not really engaging with us here at all about this,” she said.
“They either need to take some room from their path or their platform, but it can’t be left like this. The actual platform will be here with the emergency bell, the announcement bell, and the horn that each train has designed in and out of the station for safety reasons.”
Armin Krauss lives on the west side of the rail corridor and echoed Heaney’s points. He is one of a few so frustrated with the state of things that he’s hung a homemade banner calling for noise walls to be added.
“When I started moving in, there was a tree cover along the fence … dampening the sounds. The tracks were a bit further away, and it was one track. Now we have two tracks put in,” he said.
“The trains that are going through here currently have these mufflers. In my opinion, they’re still too loud.”
Krauss said rotating community relations staff mixed with unproductive community meetings organized by Metrolinx have left him and others feeling ignored. Just before speaking with CityNews and shortly after a news report on the same topic, he said transit agency staff were hand-delivering cards with links to the project’s website.
“If you build a project, you should consult the people that are affected by it, which hasn’t happened,” he said.
Noah Frank lives beside Heaney. He said there was a brief period when a noise wall looked possible for all the homes where he lives.
“Metrolinx had provided an offer to us, although it’s not an official offer; they said they would consider covering up to 50 per cent of the cost of a noise wall should we build it ourselves on our side of the property line. But most of our ask has been, ‘if you’re already building a wall, why not just integrate in a noise barrier wall?” he said.
“I don’t think that really meaningful action has been taken. There’s been some small steps that have been taken about better notification about construction timelines. But even that has sort of like faltered where we don’t really see meaningful notification, or the noise monitoring equipment isn’t actually adjacent to our properties.”
All of the concerned residents were banking on the promise of quieter trains on an electrified Barrie line, but it doesn’t appear to be imminent. Metrolinx hasn’t publicly released timeframes for overhauling the existing infrastructure, leaving noisier diesel-powered trains to operate along the corridor for an indefinite period of time.
Dr. Christopher Bergevin, an associate professor with York University who focuses on auditory biophysics, said noise and sound can be pervasive in dense urban environments.
“Sound is very good at finding ways to kind of get from one place to another because it’s just vibrations, and those vibrations are highly transmissible,” he told CityNews.
“It’s surprising how you can have a source of noise in one place that can kind of end up somewhere, kind of downstream, that is highly perceptible and can be a real issue.”
Bergevin said while our ears are “incredibly sensitive” to sound, we’ve gotten better at filtering out certain annoying types of sound. Despite that evolving filtration, it isn’t universal and quality of life can be impacted.
“It’s vibration, and everything’s connected. You know, all these buildings or everything’s touching one another. Air is a great way to kind of propagate sound and whatnot,” he said.
“Probably the easiest way to kind of get started on reducing these effects of noise is to get rid of the sources as best you can, so if you can make things that are making noise quieter, that’s going to kind of make life a little bit easier.”
CityNews contacted Metrolinx on Friday and Monday to ask for an on-camera interview about the various issues residents have been raising, but representatives said no one was available.
However, a statement issued by Metrolinx’s media relations office said planning for GO Transit expansion continues, including electrification efforts. Potential timeframes and potential next steps weren’t included in the statement.
“We recognize that noise mitigation is important to our communities, and we remain committed to making thoughtful, effective decisions that balance long-term benefits with minimizing immediate disruptions,” the statement said.
“Feasibility of noise walls within the Bloor-Lansdowne station were assessed by the design-builder of the project, who concluded that there was limited space for the construction of the walls in that particular location.
“Metrolinx has been studying point-of-emission noise mitigation that may prove more effective in mitigating noise.”
The statement noted the bells are needed for safety purposes and are only used “when necessary.”
Meanwhile, all the residents CityNews spoke with said they are supportive of transit and expanding access.
They launched a website with a petition to get support and raise awareness amid ongoing hopes Metrolinx will reassess the situation given the impacts to multiple Toronto neighbourhoods for years to come.
“We’re advocates of transit, but we want this to be implemented in a thoughtful way,” Frank said.
“We’re not against the train station. I think it’s a good addition. What we’re asking is that the train station is built responsibly with a protective wall that shields the noise from the neighbours,” Krauss said.
“We’d really love Metrolinx to come and properly meet with our community, listen to what we’re saying, read the petition, see how many people really are interested in solving this issue because it affects a lot more people than Metrolinx would like to make out,” Heaney added.
Add CityNews Toronto as a trusted source on Google to see more local stories from us.
