What happened after the last supervised consumption site closed

News Room
By News Room 28 Min Read

How have things changed in Ottawa since the last remaining Consumption and Treatment Services sites closed in June? The folks who once relied on them have lost a lot.

One thing Ottawa lost when its last supervised consumption sites closed in June was a weekly basketball game.

On Wednesday afternoons, some clients of the Sandy Hill Community Health Centre and Shepherds of Good Hope got together to play at the Union Basketball Court in Bordeleau Park — between King Edward Avenue and the Rideau River — or, when the weather turned, inside the Routhier Community Centre on Guigues Avenue.

It was a small program — sometimes only three or five people came. Some played basketball. Others played badminton, or just tossed a ball around, or simply sat and talked. The point was to spend some time together outside a world in which so much of the day was devoted to survival.

Those outings, says Sandy Hill program director Dean Dewar, helped people take steps towards treatment. During the roughly six months it operated, Dewar says the program got more people to detox than they were seeing through the consumption service itself.

“When people have a meaningful daily activity, it really makes them want to do something,” he says. “It also starts the process of, ‘Well, I’m not going to use for two hours today,’ and then, ‘Oh, I can actually not use for two hours.’”

But when the Ontario government withdrew its funding for Consumption and Treatment Services (CTS) sites, staff and money disappeared or had to be redirected. Priorities shifted.

At Sandy Hill, the basketball ended.

The province’s stated goal in closing CTS sites was to move people toward treatment and recovery — at Homelessness and Addiction Recovery Treatment, or HART, hubs — while making communities safer.

But in doing so, the province halted one of the ways to help people get there.

Sandy Hill’s cleanup program also suffered. It offered clients two-hour shifts picking up litter in the neighbourhood, paying them $15 an hour. It was a daily program that, without CTS funding, was reduced to once weekly.

It provided money, of course. But it also gave people somewhere to be, work to do and someone to talk with — some normalcy in an otherwise chaotic day. Walking beside a staff member while picking up garbage, a person might discuss housing, or something they used to enjoy, or what they wanted to change. The conversations didn’t have to begin with drugs.

According to Dewar, a private donor stepped in recently, allowing the centre to boost the cleanup program to three days a week. But that money will only last until the end of March.

At Ottawa Inner City Health, Tabitha Morris, supervisor of peer engagement programs, described outings to bowling alleys, hockey games and movies. One worker organized taxis to take 27 people to a cinema, where each could choose the movie they wanted to see, while the worker stayed in the lobby with their belongings.

After an outing to an indoor mini-putt, Morris took a group to a nearby Afghan restaurant, where they were welcomed. One woman, Morris recalls, ordered salmon, something she hadn’t had in 15 years.

“It’s the experiences, being able to play bingo, being able to do regular things, and not feel like you’re a burden on society, that you’re actually a part of it,” she says.

Some outings have continued, supported in part by other funding. But with fewer staff — Inner City Health lost much of its non-nursing workforce with the CTS closure — accompanying clients to medical appointments takes precedence. Reliably sustaining other activities has become much more difficult — at times impossible.

The consistency matters. Morris says repeated losses can make people reluctant to invest in another worker or program, viewing them as simply more disappointments waiting to happen.

These probably aren’t the things people pictured when Ontario withdrew funding. Needles, booths and drugs, perhaps. But basketball layups, street cleaning and three hours watching Avatar?

The Trailer on Murray Street — once Ottawa’s busiest supervised consumption site — also provided people somewhere to keep identification and documents safe, receive messages, and meet social and housing workers. Some of that help continues, Morris says, but without the same round-the-clock access.

We’re told that supervised consumption connected people to care and, potentially, treatment. Less obvious was how those connections were made.

Rob Boyd, Inner City Health’s executive director, says that if you ask housed and unhoused people what they enjoyed doing when they were younger, the lists will be much the same. Ask them when they last did them, however, and the answers will be vastly different.

Restoring those opportunities, Boyd argues, is part of treatment — building interests, relationships and responsibilities that can compete with substance use. Giving people something to look forward to, and something they want to keep.

Meanwhile, at the Centretown Community Health Centre, the pressure to respond to immediate crises is consuming time and resources needed to help people become more stable.

Centretown’s executive director, Michelle Hurtubise, says clinics that help people obtain identification, file back taxes and work towards housing are being cancelled several times a week because staff are needed for crisis response. She has diverted money from other programs to add three staff to the help with the crises, and says it still isn’t enough.

The CTS closures, she adds, aren’t the only cause. But the consequence is clear: resources being pulled into dealing with emergencies today mean that work that could help prevent tomorrow’s isn’t getting done.

***

Chantal Donnelly, 50, regularly used the Sandy Hill and Trailer sites to inject Dilaudid. She also smokes crack, which she wasn’t allowed to consume inside the sites.

Along with medical care, the sites provided something equally important: a community that cared about whether she lived.

Now she consumes outdoors, looking for somewhere private — an alleyway, say, or behind a dumpster. She doesn’t like people watching her. She uses alone much more often.

“Who would know if something went wrong — if you overdosed?” I asked.

“Nobody would know,” she replied.

Asked whether that worries her, she said she hasn’t thought about it. Asked more broadly about safety since the sites closed, however, she said she doesn’t feel safe at all. She worries about being robbed, assaulted and not knowing whom to trust.

Donnelly estimates she used CTS about 10 times a day, spending 30 minutes inside each visit. That meant roughly five hours a day in places where she was known and people could notice if something went wrong.

Now, much of that time is spent out of sight.

“We’re not spending the time with them anymore,” says Sunny Taggart, a staff member at Sandy Hill.

The reduction in Sandy Hill’s cleanup program has also cost Donnelly income. I asked what she had used her earnings for.

“My habit,” she replied.

“So how do you pay for it now?”

“Back to the same thing,” she said. “Robbery, prostitution, home invasion.”

Donnelly is also a Block Leader through Ottawa Inner City Health, helping clean the neighbourhood of used needles and pipes, and respond when others are in trouble. She has received CPR training. She contributes to the community even as she feels increasingly abandoned herself.

Boyd says that any lasting improvements in public safety must involve the people often perceived as the source of the problem. The Block Leader program gives them a role in making their own community safer.

Morris adds that Block Leaders use their earnings in different ways, including paying rent. Some have progressed into staff positions or outside employment.

The loss Donnelly describes extends beyond her relationships with health workers to the people she once regarded as her street family. Boyd and Dewar both report a more fractured and more aggressive atmosphere among the community of people who use drugs.

Donnelly describes that change bluntly.

“We don’t have each other’s backs anymore. We don’t look out for each other. We don’t love each other. There’s no such thing as love. It’s just money and dope.

“I’ve never felt so alone.”

***

The province’s decision to close CTS sites came with two promises: better access to treatment and recovery, and safer communities.

So I asked the Ministry of Health what data it had collected to compare conditions before and after Ottawa’s closures, including overdoses, deaths, public safety and treatment.

The response emphasized spending. Twenty-nine HART Hubs, including two in Ottawa, supported by a $560-million investment. More than 500,000 client interactions. Other provincial investments in mental health and addictions services.

There was one mortality statistic.

“The Office of the Chief Coroner has shown a 43 per cent decrease in opioid-related deaths since HART Hubs opened,” wrote Satnam Grewal, a spokesperson for Health Minister Sylvia Jones.

A substantial decline would be welcome, but I had difficulty reconciling the claim with the coroner’s figures. So I asked the coroner’s office to explain.

Turns out the 43 per cent figure referred only to Toronto, not Ottawa or Ontario as a whole. Further, it compared 2024 with 2025, rather than measuring the decline from the opening of the hubs.

The annual figures show a decline of about 44 per cent. My review of the monthly figures shows that almost all of that reduction occurred before the first HART hubs opened in April 2025.

Similar decreases in opioid-related deaths in 2025, the coroner’s office added, reflect the continuation of a trend that began in Q3 2024 and was observed in most regions in North America.

So the ministry is being misleading by suggesting the decrease in opioid deaths was the result of CTS sites closing or HART hubs opening.

According to Boyd, it was a decrease in the toxicity of illicit drugs last year that led to fewer overdoses and deaths. But those numbers, he warns, have begun climbing again.

In September, Ottawa’s medical officer of health, Dr. Trevor Arnason, told the Board of Health that reports of discarded needles, glass pipes, pill bottles and other garbage were increasing downtown. The consumption sites, he noted, had been effective at disposing of supplies and monitoring their surrounding areas. Service providers were also reporting more people needing help and seeking services. He cautioned, though, that it was still early to understand the health and community effects of the closures.

In the 16 weeks following the closure of Ottawa’s two remaining CTS sites in June, there were 1,161 suspected drug overdose visits to emergency departments at Ottawa hospitals, an increase of about six per cent over the same period a year ago.

The number of suspected drug-related deaths in Ottawa climbed at a greater rate: 55 between June 15 and Sept. 28 this year, compared to 48 over the same period a year ago, almost a 15-per cent increase.

These figures don’t establish that the closures caused the increases. The unpredictable drug supply and other factors also affect overdoses and deaths.

But the figures show that the closures have been followed by worsening outcomes on these measures.

Sometimes I wonder if I’ve seen those worst-case outcomes in person — and didn’t even stop walking.

***

On a recent Tuesday morning, as I strolled along George Street between interviews for this story, I came across a man lying mostly on the sidewalk, his head and upper torso extending out over the road.

Jennifer O’Neill, a ByWard/Lowertown resident, was crouched beside him, on the phone with 911.

My first reaction was to keep walking. The situation, after all, appeared under control. Instead, I stopped to ask O’Neill if I could help.

The 911 operator asked if the man could be roused.

I tried, shaking his left shoulder. Nothing.

Is this how a life ends, I wondered?

We were asked if there was a nearby defibrillator we could use. O’Neill and I both looked around us, somewhat helplessly.

The operator asked me to put one hand on the man’s rib cage and tell him each time the man breathed in and out. There were uncomfortably long pauses, then several breaths close together, then another extended pause.

I had a naloxone kit, which reverses the effects of opioid overdoses, but it was in my car, three blocks away. Surely emergency responders would arrive before I could retrieve it, I thought.

They did — police, paramedics and firefighters.

Marc-Antoine Deschamps, of the Ottawa Paramedic Service, later told me the breathing pattern I described sounded consistent with someone who might be overdosing. He couldn’t confirm the man’s treatment, but said he ultimately walked away.

I don’t know whether the man ever used a CTS, or whether an open site would have prevented what happened.

But O’Neill says she’s becoming a little too accustomed to encountering people who need help.

She grew up in the Market, moved to Barrhaven a dozen years ago, and returned to the Market four years ago. Since coming back, she says she has seen more open drug use, including an increase since the CTS sites closed.

She estimates she’s called 911 four or five times in the past year in response to people in distress. She only wishes more people would.

“As I was approaching the man, people were like kind of glancing in his direction and then carrying on,” she recalls. “I was like, ‘Oh, for God’s sakes! How hard is it to call 911?’”

O’Neill wants her 12-year-old daughter to learn compassion. Sometimes, when O’Neill stops to help someone, her daughter urges her to keep walking. O’Neill’s sister worries about putting the youngster in a difficult situation.

“I think I’m teaching her empathy,” O’Neill says.

Deschamps worries about people becoming desensitized to what they see. Someone sleeping on a park bench is different from someone unresponsive on the ground, he says.

O’Neill keeps stopping. But she says residents need more preparation for these encounters: naloxone training, readily available kits and clearer signs showing where to find defibrillators.

Later that same day, she checked in on a woman outside Giant Tiger, and gave her her jacket because she was cold.

But then, O’Neill was exhausted.

“I couldn’t mentally handle it,” she says.

***

At Somerset West Community Health Centre, where its former CTS became a HART hub, executive director Suzanne Obiorah sees promise in providing housing and the supports people need to keep it.

But she cautions against framing the argument as either/or choices between supervised consumption, treatment, abstinence and enforcement. People, she stresses, need different kinds of help at different times, and eliminating one service doesn’t erase the needs it was addressing.

“When we talk about our current situation in removing a service, we created a gap to care,” she says.

She describes what’s possible when someone who has experienced chronic homelessness finds a stable home — they can start thinking about such things as school, medical care and counselling.

“Quite honestly,” she says, “that starts with housing.”

Boyd, too, acknowledges that former CTS clients have benefited from HART services and housing. His concern is for those who haven’t made the connection.

Access, meanwhile, also means being able to find your way through the system. Jacques Periard, a Block Leader who, as a crack smoker didn’t use CTS sites, and was homeless when we spoke, calls it “the age of the pamphlet.”

“I don’t know what they’re doing with the homeless prevention money,” he says. “When I call somewhere, they’ll pass me on to another place, then they’ll pass me on to another place, and they’ll pass me on,” he says. “That just gets discouraging.”

Hurtubise notes that supervised consumption sites were operating without enough funding to address the demand. “If you do not provide adequate resources to the system, then the overflow of it becomes a problem of management,” she says.

Obiorah points to a similar challenge for HART hubs — making their services available at the required scale. At last count, she says, just under 1,000 people were actively engaged with Somerset West’s HART hub, but they only have housing arrangements for up to 90.

Those figures don’t provide an apples-to-apples comparison — not everyone using the hub necessarily needs supportive housing — but they do suggest the limits of the help that’s available.

“What is the plan to scale?” Hurtubise asks.

***

One thing promised by politicians in the aftermath of the CTS closures would be safer neighbourhoods.

Lowertown Community Association president Josiah Frith says he is perfectly safe when he walks down the street.

“My children are perfectly safe when they walk down the street,” he adds.

But the community of people who use drugs? “Not safe,” he says. “And that’s really where we need to focus our attention.”

He sees more obvious public consumption around existing hotspots, but without a corresponding spread into residential Lowertown.

Frith’s predecessor, Sylvie Bigras, also hasn’t noticed a major change around her home on St. Andrew Street, a couple blocks north of the Shepherds of Good Hope. She supports supervised consumption, but objects to the concentration of so many shelters, drop-ins and services in such a small area of Ottawa.

“You should have supervised consumption clinics, almost like with every medical clinic in the city,” she suggests. People stay downtown because the services are there, she argues. Providing help elsewhere would allow other communities to share the responsibility.

Hazel Moon has a more painful experience of the streets around one of the former CTS sites.

The Lowertown resident, who uses a walker, says a man outside the Shepherds shoved her backwards as she passed the shelter this summer on her way to buy groceries. Others outside the shelter intervened. A woman helped Moon to a nearby bus stop, where an ambulance was called. Moon spent three days in hospital with a concussion and has experienced memory problems since the incident.

There’s no evidence linking the assault to the closures. But Moon say she’s angry with the Shepherds for allowing the congregation, and said the people shouldn’t be there. When I asked what she thought the solution was, her answer was immediate.

“Programs,” she said. “They need things to do during the day. Programs, education, job training. They’re standing out there all day with nothing to do and nowhere to go.”

She nodded when I described the basketball and cleanup programs.

“If they’re just doing nothing, how are they getting out of the situation they’re in? They’re not meeting people, they’re not getting job skills.”

***

Chantal Donnelly once had something to look forward to.

Her granddaughter was seven months old when we recently spoke, living in North Bay with Donnelly’s son. Donnelly hasn’t met her.

Before the consumption sites closed, she says, she was attending appointments and reducing her drug use. She was beginning to feel she could make the trip.

“I was just slowing down,” she says.

Slowing down felt good. The people around her — the workers and her street family — helped her feel she was capable of doing something more.

“They just made me feel like I was good enough to do something.”

But she says she’s been using more heavily since the closures. She has lost support and confidence. The visit now feels impossible.

“I’m not good enough,” she says, crying.

Donnelly isn’t ready for treatment, she says. Does she think she might quit one day?

“Hopefully.”

There’s a gap between that hope and being able to act on it. It’s a gap that needs to be filled not just with housing and medical care, but with paid work, recreation, somewhere to go, and people who know your name.

During our conversation, a worker comes into the room. The cleanup crew is heading out in 10 minutes, and there’s a spot for Donnelly if she wants.

She does.

For two hours, she’ll have somewhere to go, something to do and people to do it with.

The Citizen newsroom is proud to report important stories like this one. If you would like to support our work and help our team continue to tell longform, deeply-reported journalism, please consider purchasing a digital subscription. ottawacitizen.com/subscribe

Share This Article
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *